What Is Peer Review - 960 Words

The literature review What is peer review? Peer review is the evaluation of scholarly and academic articles by other researchers or scientists who are expert in the field and qualified enough to perform a reasonably neutral review. It is an indispensable part of the process of the scholarly publication. Most academic journals rely on scholarly peer review, or refereeing, to help editors evaluate the quality of articles submitted to their journals. The review process is a skill, which is learned through practice and experience (British Ecological Society, 2013). The purpose of peer review The primary purpose of the peer review is to assess the quality of the research and the paper as well. It provides the journal editor with the information needed to reach a reasonable decision. According to Hames (2008), peer review is an important part of the quality control mechanism used to determine what it should be published, and what it should not. Any scholarly work or research will not be considered until it has been validated by peer review. The peer review process acts as a filter for interest and relevance to the field being targeted by a journal. Peer review, therefore, should serve numerous purposes as follows: - To help select quality articles for publication based on their scientific merit and validity and their methodology. - To ensure that the work is properly described and the results presented have been interpreted appropriately. - To improve the manuscript (improveShow MoreRelatedScholarly Bibliography On Scholarly Journals Essay866 Words   |  4 Pages Definitions of terms Scholarly peer review Scholarly peer review, also known as refereeing, is the process of subjecting an author’s scholarly manuscript to the scrutiny of others who are experts and working in the same field (Ware 2013). Scholarly/academic journal Scholarly journal, also called as academic/scientific/refereed journal or very often peer-reviewed journal, is a peer-reviewed/refereed periodical in which scholarship relating to a particular academic discipline is published. AcademicRead MoreThe Advantages of Collaborating on a Project708 Words   |  3 Pagesï » ¿Peer Review Collaboration Introduction What are the major advantages of collaborating on a project? Collaboration between students is part of the learning process, in fact collaboration †¦fosters effective learning and community building, according to Andrea Cottrell with California State University in Sacramento. In a classroom situation, collaboration with peers helps students be comfortable with each other, and from a teaching aspect peer-review collaboration gain proficiency in their writtenRead MorePeer Review825 Words   |  4 PagesENGL112 Peer Review Worksheet INSTRUCTIONS: Peer Reviews will be conducted in class discussion forums during Week 7. Be sure to review the Lecture and the Discussion area for additional details and guidance. Please complete the following steps below, returning a separate peer review worksheet for each of the two classmates whose papers you review. This assignment is worth 50 points. * You will receive 10 points for submitting your draft by the required deadline. * You will receive 20 pointsRead MorePeer Review On Peer Reviews1653 Words   |  7 PagesPeer review is a composition tool that has been used at many different levels of schooling for a very long time. Some people find it to be unnecessary and many students just see it as a way to pick out spelling and grammatical errors. However, the goal of peer review is to get more out of it than just basic editing. In Peer Editing In the 21st Century College Classroom: Do Beginning Composition Students Truly Reap The Benefits?, the author, Lindsey Jesnek, makes the argument that lower levelRead MoreScholarly Journals Versus Popular Magazines876 Words   |  4 Pagesread or write some scholarly journals when they become a university student. Many of student do not know what kind of article can be called scholarly journals? Anyhow, those be loved by the people of articles always are not form scholarly journals in our daily lives. Like popular magazines. We can see citizen read a magazine on the bus stop chair but never see people read a scholarly journal. what are the different with the common popular magazines in bookstore? Which kind of articles are more suitRead MoreUtilization Review ( Ur ) Can Constitute Practicing Medicine1157 Words   |  5 PagesIn some way, Utilization Review (UR) can constitute â€Å"practicing medicine† because UR is an evaluated healthcare services based on standards of care, treatment guidelines, and evidence-base medicine (Wolter, Beeman, Lynch, n.d.). The provider must address UR in the proposed decision. UR is a system designed for monitoring, evaluating and efficiency for services provided. UR should not be limited to only medical professionals licensed to practice medicine. Any provider, licensed or unlicensedRead MoreThe Common Mission Of Most Universities889 Words   |  4 Pagesneeds, generating strategies to meet these needs and then implementing the strategies (Hacker, 2009). Peer assessment is an authentic too l that can be used to evaluate student learning while contributing to the growth of critical thinking and metacognitive skills. Peer assessment is defined as the process where students critique each other’s work for either formative or summative purposes. Peer review can be effectively utilized in courses of almost any discipline in both face-to-face and online formatsRead MoreWriting Reflection873 Words   |  4 Pagesdifferent activities that contributed to helping me become a better writer. Informal writing assignments, class discussions, peer review sessions and the writing center were just some of the resources available to me that helped progress not only my writing ability but my overall reading writing analysis skills as well. Not only did I make new relationships with my peers, these relationships also helped me understand the content more thoroughly, work out any problems that I had with my ideas, andRead MoreHow Effectively And Appropriately Am I Performing985 Wo rds   |  4 PagesHow Effectively/Appropriately Am I Performing this/these Genre-Attempt(s): Have taken detailed peer review notes; make your peer-reviewer(s) go into troubleshooting detail on workshop days: Insist that they look for problems or flaws. Deal with more than sentence-level issues (grammar, punctuation, etc.), but do mention those if that’s an issue. Then, go beyond what the peer-reviewer(s) might have said. Write also a self-assessment. While I usually discourage writing a 5-paragraph essay, thatRead MoreMy First Class Of The Year856 Words   |  4 PagesIt’s my first class of the year, not knowing what to expect I entered the room with absolute nervousness and fear, after all it was my second English class of college. Although, I’ve never been quite fond of writing in the past, I’ve always done well in the English class in high school. I had yet to work to hard for my grade and no English course I had taken proved to be a challenge i n my eyes. But, I have always been a huge procrastinator, if not one of the biggest when it comes to writing. Most